Author: Marissa Meyer
Publisher: Feiwel & Friends
Release Date: January 03, 2012
Page Count: 387
Source: The Library
Read Between: November 07 - November 09, 2012
Buy It: Amazon / B&N / The Book Depository
*Sigh*... Cinder, Cinder, Cinder. Where did you and I go wrong? You started out so strong and promising. I had to many recommendations to read you by other bloggers & co-workers alike and yet I couldn't find myself loving you at all. Sure I like you, but how I so expected to love you.
I have read and heard so many good things for Cinder by Marissa Meyer. I fully thought I was going to absolutely adore this book. I mean, it's set in the future, it has cyborgs. It's a retelling of Cinderella, which is one of my all time favorite fairy-tales. And for crying out loud it has elements of Sailor Moon, my ALL TIME favorite anime, within it. What isn't there to love about it?
The answer to that question, unfortunately, is quite a bit.
First off, my biggest issue with this story, by far was the fact that the foreshadowing was horrendous. Within the first not even 10% of the book or so, I had already figured out the "great, big secret" (note my sarcasm here) of who Cinder really was. If you have two (functioning) eyes within your head, it's not that hard to figure out. Which makes it even more annoying that it took until the VERY end of the book for Cinder to figure this out. And she didn't even figure it out on her own, even though hint after hint after obvious hint was through her way. Not it was told to her by another. It was like... *facepalm* how have you not figured this out yet???
I also think that it may be a bad thing that it has already been revealed to all readers what the next 3 books in this series are going to be titled. Because of this simple fact, I have already practically figured out, which girls are going to play who in which book of the next books to come. Just another case of the horrendous foreshadowing of this first book. I don't want to know who all the characters are going to be already... It totally ruins the element of surprise for the next books. I guess I will just have to keep my fingers crossed and hope that Marissa has something up her sleeve that she didn't reveal in all the foreshadowing she had going on.
Another issue I had with Cinder, was the fact that Ms. Meyer turned the Queen of the Moon into the villain. For me, who grew up watching (and adoring) everything that had to do with Sailor Moon (& it is obvious that a lot of this book was inspired by that anime), it's hard... no impossible... for me to see people of the Moon as villains. I grew up wishing the Moon Kingdom was real and that I could have been born in the time of the Silver Millennium (even if I had to die by the hands of Queen Beryl). So to read a book, that turned the Moon people almost evil... well it physically hurt me inside to read something like that. I felt like it was a betrayal to Sailor Moon, itself, who was the ultimate protector of Earth. But then again, this could be completely bias. Since I already love the Moon, as soon as I realized they were the "evil" in this book, I turned against it. That thought could have some valued points to it as well.
The romance also left a lot to be wanted. My friend kept telling me, "It's one of the sweetest romances that I have read in a long time." Now while I respect my friend and her opinion, I must kindly beg to differ from this. Maybe I am to in search of a romance as amazing as Clara and Tucker's was in Unearthly. It felt more forced then anything else. I could see how a friendship was building between Cinder and Kai, but not love. Maybe that's just me though.
Overall, Cinder left me just barely interested enough to want to pick up Scarlet when it comes out and see how Ms. Meyer continues this story. Maybe she will be able to change my mind in the next book and I will see why everybody has been raving over this series.